Skip to main content
search
0

Just when you think Wisconsin couldn’t possibly be blessed with another world-class public golf destination, there’s another incredibly exciting project taking shape in the western part of the state.

And this one has the potential to be truly extraordinary.

Whitehall Sands is a new destination golf development being built on the site of the former Hi-Crush frac sand mine in Whitehall, about ten minutes from Arcadia and halfway between La Crosse and Eau Claire.

The project is the vision of acclaimed golf course architect and Wisconsin native Jay Blasi, who first visited the property in 2020 and immediately recognized its potential. Working alongside longtime friends Derrick and Mitchell Bushman and others involved in bringing the project to life, Blasi is transforming this remarkable piece of land into an 18-hole championship golf course with on-site lodging and additional amenities also planned.

I’ve had the privilege of visiting and photographing Whitehall Sands twice since August, and I can tell you that it’s one of the most dramatic properties I’ve ever seen for a golf project.

My first visit was back in August, when I met General Manager Jase Baldauf before sunrise to tour the property, get a feel for the routing and capture some initial photography and video for the development’s marketing efforts.

I’d seen some renderings beforehand, and knowing the course was being built in a former sand mine certainly had me intrigued. But even with an idea of what to expect, I wasn’t prepared for the sheer scale of the place.

We started at the red barn near the entrance and made our way up a long sand road toward the future clubhouse site before heading farther into the property. By the time we reached the sixth and seventh holes, I was beginning to realize just how enormous this former mine really is.

There are exposed walls more than 90 feet high, enormous expanses of sand and elevation changes that are difficult to appreciate until you’re standing there looking down into the mine. And as incredible as that landscape is, the surrounding countryside is every bit as impressive.

Rolling farmlands, heavily wooded hills and deep coulees stretch for miles in seemingly every direction. On that particular morning, many of the valleys were filled with fog, making an already beautiful part of Wisconsin even more spectacular.

It was one of the most memorable mornings I’ve had photographing golf, and an incredible introduction to a property that I expect we’ll be hearing a whole lot more about in the years ahead.

A Golf Course Years in the Making

For Jay Blasi, Whitehall Sands is much more than another golf course design project.

Blasi grew up in Madison, attended the University of Wisconsin and has built an impressive architectural resumé that includes work at Chambers Bay, SentryWorld, The Patriot, Poppy Ridge and several other acclaimed facilities. But the opportunity to create a new course in his home state, especially in a part of Wisconsin where he has family ties, has been particularly meaningful.

As Blasi told me about his first visit to the property:

“Having grown up in Wisconsin it has always been a goal to design a new course in the state. I first visited the Whitehall Sands property in 2020 and was in awe of the natural beauty of the area and the dramatic scale of the mine.”

“Then when I dove deeper and realized I had family ties to the region, met the community leaders and really understood how this project could reclaim a degraded landscape and help support the town, it became clear that this was the spot in Wisconsin. Having the opportunity to bring it to life with my friend Derrick Bushman is truly a dream come true!”

There’s an especially interesting connection between Whitehall Sands and Chambers Bay in Washington, where Blasi served as project architect while working with Robert Trent Jones II. That project also involved transforming a former sand and gravel mine into a world-class public golf course, one that went on to host the 2015 U.S. Open and resides in Golf Digest’s top 20 public courses in America.

The parallels are hard to ignore, but Whitehall Sands has a character all its own.

Rather than trying to disguise the property’s industrial past, Blasi is incorporating the exposed mine walls, sandy corridors and dramatic elevation changes directly into the golf. At the same time, the routing ventures outside the mine into the surrounding hills and countryside, providing a completely different look and feel.

The first three holes explore the western side of the property, while the ninth through 11th move away from the mine to the south before returning to its edge. Others play alongside towering exposed walls or dive directly into the former mine itself.

It’s that variety, and the contrast between the rugged mine and the beautiful western Wisconsin countryside, that I think will make Whitehall Sands such a fascinating place to experience.

Golf In, Around and Above the Mine

Whitehall Sands is still raw enough that finding individual holes isn’t always easy. During my August visit, much of the routing existed as stakes across an enormous property rather than recognizable golf holes, so having Jase along to point out tees, landing areas and future green sites was invaluable. Returning in October, I could begin to appreciate how much progress had already been made as the routing started taking shape.

The planned course will likely stretch to a bit over 7,000 yards from the back tees (particular yardages are still being worked on in the field) with firm fescue fairways, bold bentgrass greens and dramatic out-of-play areas designed to complement the natural terrain. And if there’s one thing that stands out most to me about the routing, it’s the variety.

The opening three holes occupy the western side of the property, away from the most dramatic sections of the former mine but with hordes of drama themselves. The first reminds me of the opening hole at Greywalls in Michigan’s Upper Peninsula, plunging downhill into a valley with a fairway that runs from left to right.

Drone photograph of the par four 1st hole at Whitehall Sands in Whitehall, Wisconsin by Paul Seifert of WiscoGolfAddict.com for Whitehall Sands
The 1st at Whitehall Sands, descending into the valley

The third then climbs back uphill toward the clubhouse and towering mine walls, offering an early glimpse into the adventures yet to come.

Drone photograph of the 3rd hole at Whitehall Sands in Whitehall, Wisconsin by Paul Seifert of WiscoGolfAddict.com for Whitehall Sands
The 3rd at Whitehall Sands, playing nearly 100 feet uphill from the 2nd hole green site (bottom-middle)

The fourth is a fascinating par three with an unusually long tee complex stretching along the top of a steep hillside, offering a wide range of distances and dramatically different perspectives of the green tucked into the slope well below. With the exposed sand of the former mine on one side and sweeping views of the surrounding countryside on the other, it’s an incredible setting for the layout’s first short hole.

Drone photograph of the par three 4th hole at Whitehall Sands in Whitehall, Wisconsin, taken by Paul Seifert of WiscoGolfAddict.com
The 4th at Whitehall Sands, playing into the valley
Drone photograph of the par three 4th hole at Whitehall Sands in Whitehall, Wisconsin, taken by Paul Seifert of WiscoGolfAddict.com
Stakes show where 4 green will be built on the hilside

Then comes seven.

This short par four promises to be one of the signature moments at Whitehall Sands, featuring an infinity-style green perched high above the surrounding terrain with the enormous exposed mine walls providing a spectacular backdrop. Even as little more than a raw construction site on my first visit, I couldn’t help but stop and spend a couple minutes envisioning what this hole will look like once shaped and grassed in fine fescue.

It may eventually become the photograph that defines Whitehall Sands, with an intimidating approach shot towards a green perched at the edge of a multi-story drop straight into the mine.

Drone photograph of the par four 7th hole and its infinity green at Whitehall Sands in Whitehall, Wisconsin, taken by Paul Seifert of WiscoGolfAddict.com
The 7th and its infinity green at Whitehall Sands
Drone photograph of the par four 7th hole and its infinity green at Whitehall Sands in Whitehall, Wisconsin, taken by Paul Seifert of WiscoGolfAddict.com
The 7th, from above the 8th green

The eighth follows with another extraordinary encounter with the mine, a par three whose back tee plays across a deep canyon towards a green beyond the exposed wall. The actual carry of the corner will be relatively short – under 100 yards – but the visual intimidation will be quite real.

Drone photograph of the par three 8th hole played across the mine walls at Whitehall Sands in Whitehall, Wisconsin, taken by Paul Seifert of WiscoGolfAddict.com
The par three 8th will play across the corner of the mine walls

The ninth through eleventh holes then take players away from the mine and into another section of the property’s beautiful rolling countryside before returning to the edge of the quarry at the 11th green. Perched high atop one of the mine’s exposed walls, this spectacular infinity green overlooks the 12th fairway on a ledge 20 feet below, with yet another enormous drop into the mine beyond that.

Drone photograph of the par four 11th hole and its infinity green at Whitehall Sands in Whitehall, Wisconsin, taken by Paul Seifert of WiscoGolfAddict.com
The 11th at Whitehall Sands plays back from the prairie setting toward the mine, above the elevated 12th fairway

And then comes the 12th.

This par four may feature the most intimidating tee shot on the entire course, requiring a carry of approximately 240 yards from the back tees into the prevailing wind and across an enormous chasm that drops roughly 70 feet below.

“This could end up being the most unused tee box in the state when the course opens,” Jase told me.

During my October visit, I had to give it a try. While my tee shot wouldn’t have cleared the canyon, it did show there’s another way to play it: toward the fairly narrow strip of fairway running along the mine wall to the left.

My tee shot is image 13 in this Instagram post:

It’s difficult to describe the feeling of standing over a golf ball with that much empty space between you and the other side. There are certainly plenty of dramatic forced carries in golf, but very few I’ve encountered that look anything like this one. It’s exactly the type of moment that will make Whitehall Sands such an exhilarating golf experience.

Drone photograph of the par four 12th hole at Whitehall Sands in Whitehall, Wisconsin, taken by Paul Seifert of WiscoGolfAddict.com
The fairway on 12 at Whitehall Sands

The course’s closing six-hole stretch should be incredible, too, featuring a quirky sequence of par three, three, five, four, three and five.

As I’ve always said, I love a quirky scorecard.

There’s not much better than the alternating par fives and threes at Lawsonia’s Links Course between the ninth and 15th holes, or finishing the front nine and beginning the back with consecutive par threes at Pacific Dunes. I love when an architect is willing to embrace an unconventional routing rather than force a traditional sequence of holes onto a property simply because that’s what golf enthusiasts and raters are accustomed to seeing.

And Blasi certainly doesn’t shy away from that here.

The back-to-back par threes on the 13th and 14th will vary significantly in yardage and character, followed by a par five stretching more than 600 yards south between the mine walls.

Drone photograph of the long par five 15th hole at Whitehall Sands in Whitehall, Wisconsin, taken by Paul Seifert of WiscoGolfAddict.com
The long par five 15th careens through the interior mine walls

From there, the final stretch eventually brings players to the 17th, an uphill par three played into a steep, exposed-stone hillside.

Drone photograph of the par three 17th hole at Whitehall Sands in Whitehall, Wisconsin, taken by Paul Seifert of WiscoGolfAddict.com
Just wait ’til you see what Blasi has in store for the par three 17th!

The course will finish with a long par five that will play down into the mine before climbing back out and toward the elevated clubhouse area. It should be a spectacular finish to a round that takes golfers around, over and through the former Hi-Crush mine, and one that players will be very happy to have a caddy or golf cart along for the adventure for.

Drone photograph of the par five 18th hole at Whitehall Sands in Whitehall, Wisconsin, taken by Paul Seifert of WiscoGolfAddict.com
The 18th at Whitehall Sands, playing from near the 12th tee into the mine, then up and out toward the clubhouse area

Turning an Extraordinary Landscape into Golf

As impressive as the property is, transforming it into a playable golf course is an enormous undertaking.

This isn’t a situation where an architect can simply find 18 natural golf holes, make a few adjustments, install irrigation and drainage and begin planting grass.

The mine’s tremendous elevation changes, exposed sand and rugged terrain create opportunities that are rarely available in golf course construction, but they also present significant challenges.

The goal isn’t to eliminate those features. It’s to make them work for golf.

That’s where the experience and creativity of the construction team become so important.

Working alongside Blasi is Derek Dirksen, the project’s lead shaper and a highly regarded craftsman whose previous work includes SentryWorld, The Patriot and other projects with Blasi as well as with many other designers including Hurdzan & Fry (Erin Hills, the South Course at Arcadia Bluffs), David McLay Kidd (Loraloma, The Scarecrow at Gamble Sands), Andy Staples (The Match at PGA National) and many others.

I’ve had the opportunity to spend a little time with Derek on-site, and it’s fascinating to see how the raw terrain is being transformed into recognizable golf holes.

There’s an enormous amount of material being moved, with landing areas, bunkers, greens complexes and transitions between holes gradually emerging from the landscape.

And while the property itself is anything but subtle, the architectural approach is intended to be relatively minimalist, allowing the tremendous natural features to provide much of the drama.

The finished course is expected to feature firm fescue fairways and bentgrass greens, emphasizing a ground game and strategic options rather than simply demanding that players hit one precise “hero shot” after another.

It’s an ambitious vision, particularly given the challenges of establishing and maintaining fescue in Wisconsin, but one that could create a very distinctive playing experience if everything comes together as planned.

Building Something Special for Western Wisconsin

For Jay and the Bushman brothers, Whitehall Sands represents an opportunity to create something that extends beyond the golf course itself.

The brothers have deep roots in Wisconsin agriculture and are passionate golf enthusiasts, including being members at The Lido at Sand Valley.

Their vision is to establish a public golf destination that attracts visitors to western Wisconsin while also providing an economic boost to the Whitehall area.

And the location makes a great deal of sense.

Whitehall Sands sits roughly two hours from the Twin Cities, positioning it as a natural stop for golf enthusiasts traveling east into Wisconsin. With Sand Valley, SentryWorld, Kohler, Erin Hills, The Club at Lac La Belle, Destination Geneva National and so many other top-notch golf experiences farther east, it’s easy to imagine Whitehall Sands becoming part of some really memorable golf itineraries.

But with the caliber of the landscape and architecture taking shape here, it will be a destination in its own right.

Another interesting part of the Whitehall Sands story is the Herdsmen Founding Membership program, which was modeled in part after the successful founding membership program at Sand Valley. It offers a limited number of golf enthusiasts the opportunity to invest in the development from the ground up, with long-term membership benefits as the project takes shape and a recap of their investment when the property stabilizes.

From what I’ve heard, interest has far exceeded the developers’ expectations as memberships are filling more quickly than initially anticipated. Considering the success of Sand Valley and the incredible momentum Wisconsin golf has enjoyed in recent years, it’s exciting to see that same kind of enthusiasm building around a new destination in a separate part of the state.

Another Exciting Chapter for Wisconsin Golf

I probably sound like a broken record sometimes talking about how fortunate we are to live in Wisconsin and have access to so much incredible golf, but it really is remarkable how far our state has come over the past couple of decades.

Between the emergence of Erin Hills and Sand Valley, the continued evolution of Kohler and SentryWorld and exciting new projects seemingly popping up every year, Wisconsin has become one of the premier golf destinations in the country. In fact, Golf Digest ranks Wisconsin as the number 1 state in America for public golf with an astounding 11 courses on its latest list of America’s 100 Greatest Public Courses (2025).

As crazy as this sounds, I think that number will only continue to grow. There are already outstanding public courses like The Club at Lac La Belle that I believe deserve consideration, and with the continued development of Wisconsin’s golf destinations I’m confident there are more nationally recognized courses on the horizon. Whitehall Sands, in particular, is a project I could see making a significant splash when it debuts. We’ve seen new courses like Landmand in Nebraska debut among the nation’s very elite, and with the extraordinary property, architectural talent and vision behind Whitehall Sands, I wouldn’t be surprised to see it make a similarly strong first impression when the national rankings eventually catch up with it.

One of the things that excites me most about Whitehall Sands is its location. Western Wisconsin has plenty of good golf and some absolutely beautiful countryside, but it hasn’t seen the same level of destination golf development as other parts of the state. With Jay Blasi leading the design, Derek Dirksen overseeing the shaping, OGM Golf handling operations and a passionate ownership group behind the project, there’s an incredible amount of talent and experience coming together to transform this former sand mine into something that could really put the Whitehall and Arcadia area on the map for golf enthusiasts.

There’s still plenty of work ahead, of course, with construction and grow-in continuing as the team works toward a full public opening in early 2028. But having photographed the property twice already and seen how much progress has been made in just a couple of months, I couldn’t be more excited about what’s to come.

I’ve been fortunate to photograph some incredible golf courses and developments over the years, and there’s something especially rewarding about watching one like this come together from the very beginning.

I’ll be returning to Whitehall Sands again later this month and look forward to continuing to document its progress as the golf holes take shape, the turf begins to grow in and the incredible vision for this property eventually becomes a reality. There’s a tremendous amount of potential here, and if what I’ve seen so far is any indication, I think Wisconsin golf enthusiasts are going to have another very special destination to look forward to.

For more information on Whitehall Sands, including course renderings and details about the Herdsmen Founding Membership program, visit whitehallsands.com.

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.


Discover more from WiscoGolfAddict

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Paul Seifert

Owner/Publisher/Content Creator for WiscoGolfAddict; FAA 107 commercially licensed drone pilot/artist; contributor to other golf publications including Midwest Golfing Magazine, Grass Roots and others. 16-year healthcare/long-term care industry sales/strategy/analytics professional.

Leave a Reply

Close Menu

Discover more from WiscoGolfAddict

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading